MBA Edu needs a rethink, say Dr J Sheth, SMU Dean Dr H Thomas and IMD ex President Dr P Lorange

Add Review

admin
Amit Agnihotri
Columnist & Author, MBAUniverse.com
Updated on January 10, 2014
Dr Jagdish Sheth, Dr Howard Thomas, and Professor Peter Lorange, shared their views on their recently released book -`The Business School in the Twenty First Century`, at the BIMTECH-MBAUniverse.com panel discussion, held in New Delhi on January 8.
"The crisis in management education has come about because the profile of the students entering Business Schools has changed", says Dr Jagdish Sheth.

Business Schools in the US are going through a mid-life crisis and need an alternative business model. If Indian Business Schools don’t watch out, they too are headed that way. However, not all is lost. In their 100 years of existence, B-schools have shown resilience, and shall reinvent themselves. That’s the message from the BIMTECH-MBAUniverse.com panel discussion, held in New Delhi on January 8, where management guru Dr Jagdish Sheth; Dr Howard Thomas, Dean, School of Business, Singapore Management University and Professor Peter Lorange, President of Lorange Institute of Business & former Dean of IMD Switzerland shared their views on their recently released book – ‘The Business School in the Twenty First Century.’

 

The meet was organized by BIMTECH, MBAUniverse.com and Cambridge University Press in New Delhi to highlight the learnings from hard-hitting new book “The Business School in the Twenty First Century – Emergent Challenges and New Business Models” written by Dr Jagdish Sheth , Dr Howard Thomas and Professor Peter Lorange. The book has been published by Cambridge University Press. The book addresses questions on the Status, Identity and Legitimacy of Business Schools in modern University System and the three world experts share their critical insights on management education and new business school models in the US, Europe and Asia on designing the business schools of the future and how to make them work. 

 

The meet was attended by 75 leading MBA educators, representatives of corporate India and media.  

 

Speaking on the occasion, Dr Sheth said, the crisis in management education has come about because the profile of the students entering Business Schools has changed as well as the careers they are opting for once they complete their MBA course. The curriculum, however, has not been adapted to suit the new reality.

 

Speaking from the Singapore Management University (SMU) campus via a video link, Dr Howard Thomas said, “The business schools have still not gained acceptance from businesses and are often treated with skepticism and sometimes contempt by others in the university system. The challenge for business school educators is to arrive at a new framework with respect to positioning, knowledge creation and knowledge dissemination.”

 

Dr Howard Thomas is the Dean and LKCSB Chair in Strategic Management at the Lee Kong Chian School of Business, Singapore Management University. He was the Dean of Warwick Business School for a decade (2000-10). 

 

Addressing the meet from the Lorange Institute of Business in Zurich, Dr Lorange said, “The future of management education lies in creating a new model that is based on leveraging education technology that taps the vast networks of professionals and knowledge that are outside the current MBA system. New MBA programs should be modular in nature. This innovation will allow candidates to work full-time while getting education. A lot of other innovations are possible to create the new model.”

 

Dr Lorange is the President of the Lorange Institute of Business, Zurich, and is one of the world’s foremost business school academics. He is Professor of Strategy at IMD, Switzerland, and was the President of IMD (1993-2008).

 

The meet was also addressed by leading Indian management educators. Dr Raj Dhankar, Dean of Faculty of Management Studies; Dr D K Bandopadhyay, former V C of Indraprastha University and Dr H Chaturvedi, Director, BIMTECH pointed out the critical challenges facing Business Schools in India.

 

Dr Sheth said that when Business Schools first came up, they were designed for engineers who would seamlessly move into corporations. But today, there are as many students from liberal arts joining the MBA course and most B-School graduates opt for careers in investment banking or management consultancies. “Seventy five per cent of MBAs in the US go on to management consultancies and investment banking and the curriculum was never designed for this,” said Dr Sheth.

 

According to him, that trend is catching on in India too. In marketing, the curriculum on branding taught today has become irrelevant as what is needed is grounding in social media and digital marketing but the faculty has little idea about these emerging disciplines and subjects, said Dr Sheth. Not the one to mince words, Dr Sheth said that the MBA course just taught the ‘vocabulary of the industry’ and did not transfer any in-depth knowledge.

 

Responding to a question on the future of management education by Amit Agnihotri, Chairman, MBAUniverse.com, who moderated the session, Professor Sheth said, “I am an optimist. However, not all is lost. In their 100 years of existence, B-schools have shown resilience, and shall reinvent themselves.”

 

Dr Sheth added that he was optimistic that Business Schools in India would find an alternative model. His own model: to create the ‘IITs of B-school’ by investing in an undergraduate 10+2+5 model for management education. Of this, he said in the five years, the first two years should be spent studying the liberal arts – the classics, philosophy and history. “This would teach the business leader of the future to be a humanist first,” he said.

 
CAT 2013 Results

CAT 2013 results on Jan 14; more than 15,000 candidates to get calls for IIMs

CAT 2013 Results to be declared on January 14, 2014

IIM Admission criteria 2014:  Final Selection criteria of seven older IIMs?

IIM Admission criteria 2014:  How to get shortlisted for seven Older IIMs?

New IIMs’ Common Admission Process 2014 to reduce burden on candidates

IIM Admission Process: 10,000 candidates to be shortlisted for 6 new IIMs

Solved WAT Essay topic for MBA Admission 2014

WAT Topic for MBA: 2014 General elections will be a watershed for Indian democracy

WAT Topic for MBA: Corruption is the root cause of current economic and social woes in India

WAT Topic for MBA: India`s 1.2 billion population is an asset for the country

WAT Topic for MBA: India has more skilled Human Resource

WAT Topic for MBA: Indo-US relations; how much beneficial for India

WAT Topic for MBA: FDI in multi brand retail is a boon or bane

WAT Topic for MBA: Is ASEAN a defunct Group

WAT Topic for MBA: Essay writing; fasten your belts

Essay Writing and WAT in IIMs: Role, Importance and Weightage

Click for more WAT topics for MBA

 

Solved GD Topics for MBA Admission 2014 :

GD Topic for MBA: What India gained at the WTO DOHA Round

GD topic for MBA: Political activism is the only way to root out corruption

GD Topic for MBA: New Lokpal will be effective in curbing corruption

GD Topics: Gender bias in portraying Women in Advertisements

GD Topic for MBA: RBI's new governor has taken adequate steps to improve Indian Economy

GD Topic for MBA: Corruption is the root cause for Indian Economy slowdown

GD Topic for MBA: The rise in vegetable prices is a man made farce

GD Topic for MBA: Opinion Polls be banned in pre election period

GD Topic for MBA: Should business lobbying be made legal in India?

GD Topics: Will India remain way behind China?

For any doubts and queries related to the exam pattern, preparations and other related queries about MBA entrance exams like XAT,IIFT, NMAT, SNAP, CMAT, IBSAT, MICAT and MBA Admission 2014, click here http://www.mbauniverse.com/mbau_faq/client.php

 

Following articles will provide all the key details decide which B school to apply:

MBA in Delhi/NCR

MBA in Cochin

MBA in Bangalore

MBA in Chennai

MBA in Ahmedabad

MBA in Bhubaneswar

MBA in Hyderabad

 MBA in Mumbai/

Pune

MBA in Delhi

MBA in Pune

IIM Ranchi

XLRI Jamshedpur 

FMS Delhi

SPJIMR Mumbai 

IIFT Delhi

 TAPMI Manipal

Click here to score high marks in GD PI WAT at Top B school for Admission 2014:
http://www.mbauniverse.com/gd_pi_preparation/gd_preparation.php

GD PI WAT Preparation for MBA Admission 2014

Know 10 Important Don'ts for Essay writing

GD Topic for MBA: Should business lobbying be made legal in India?

8 key points for effective Essay Writing

GD PI: Importance and Role of Group Discussion in MBA Admission 2014

GD Preparation: 7 Effective Do's to win GD for MBA admission

Personal Interview: Model questions & answers for MBA Admission 2014

GD PI: 10 important Personal Interview tips for MBA Admission 2014

Essay Writing and WAT in IIMs : Role, Importance and Weightage

Stay tuned to MBAUniverse.com for more news and updates on education events.